Compare AI visibility tools on eight points
Entry price, engines, free trial, markets, MCP, API access, answer data and method. Use the same eight questions on every tool, and see why Firemark is the one you can run from your assistant.
What to check when you compare AI visibility tools
Each point is a question to put to the vendor, and the reason it changes what you get.
Entry price and pricing unit
What does the cheapest plan cost, and what does the price scale with: prompts, engines, markets or seats?
Two tools at the same sticker price can differ by 5x in prompts or engines, and add-ons change the real cost.
Engine coverage
Which AI engines are included, which cost extra, and which are missing?
A tool that skips an engine your buyers use cannot tell you where you are absent.
Free trial
Can you test it before paying, for how long, and with what limits?
A trial is the cheapest way to test the interface, but trial limits often differ from paid limits.
Geography and language
Which countries and languages are covered, and are they limited by plan?
AI answers change by country and language, so check that the tool asks from the markets your buyers are in.
MCP and day-to-day use
Can you set up and run the tool from Claude or ChatGPT, or only read data there? Who can make changes, and which plans include it?
A tool you run from your assistant fits the work you already do there. A dashboard-only tool is one more tab to check.
API access
Is there a REST API, on which plans, and with what request limits?
If you pipe data into your own warehouse or dashboards, API gating can matter more than the plan price.
Answer-level data and export
Can you read the full AI answers, export them, and for how long are they kept?
Counts tell you that something moved. The answers tell you why.
Methodology transparency
Does the vendor publish how answers are collected, how many runs back a number, and where numbers are unreliable?
AI answers vary from one ask to the next, so a number without its sample size is hard to trust.
Firemark, Peec AI, Profound and Otterly.AI at a glance
The short version of each tool on the same eight points. Each comparison page has the full wording, sources and what to confirm yourself.
| Dimension | Firemark | Peec AI | Profound | Otterly.AI |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Entry price and pricing unit | Lite $29, Starter $79, Growth $199, Pro $499. Flat tiers, prompts 25 / 100 / 200 / 500. | Starter 50, Pro 150, Advanced 350 prompts. Check Peec for current prices. | Free trial, then custom Enterprise quote. No self-serve brand plan listed. | Lite $29 (15 prompts), Standard $189 (100), Premium $489 (400). Engine add-ons extra. |
| Engine coverage | 5 engines, set by plan (3 / 4 / 5 / 5). | Choose 3 of 6 on self-serve. Wider list on Enterprise, including Claude. | Trial: 3 engines. Enterprise: up to 9, including Claude. | 4 on every plan. AI Mode, Gemini and Claude are add-ons. |
| Free trial | One free run. | Trial button on pricing page. Terms: check Peec. | Yes: 7 days, 50 prompts, 1 region, 1 language. | Yes, no card. Length: check Otterly (7 or 14 days shown). |
| Geography and language | US English, plus French- and Spanish-speaking countries on request. | 80+ countries claimed. Per-plan limits: check Peec. | Trial: 1 region, 1 language. Enterprise: custom. | 50+ countries on all plans. |
| MCP | MCP-native. Set up, read and change tracking from Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor or any MCP client. 31 tools; any member can connect; every change waits for your approval. | Read and write. Write tools need organization-owner access. Plan gating: check Peec. | Reports, agents and prompt management; read and write. Enterprise plan. | Read and write. Standard and up, 2,000 or 5,000 calls a month. |
| API access | Read-only API on every paid plan. | Enterprise customers only. | Enterprise plan. | Standard and up, 2,000 or 5,000 requests a month. |
| Answer-level data and export | Full answers in app and API, 13 months. CSV without full answers. | Full responses via MCP. CSV and Looker Studio. Retention not found. | Raw answers via API. CSV and JSON export, all-time history on Enterprise. | Raw responses via MCP. Export on all plans. |
| Methodology transparency | Public method with minimum samples and stated limits. | Describes UI scraping. No sample-size rules found. | Help article gives no technique or sample size. | Says it scrapes like a real user. No sample size found. |
Information from Peec AI, Profound and Otterly.AI public pages, checked 2026-10-15. We have not given any tool a score. Which tool fits depends on the constraint that decides it for you.
Compare Firemark with each AI visibility tool
Each page opens with a choose-if summary, then sets out where Firemark is stronger and where the other tool is.
Peec AI vs Firemark
Choose Peec AI if you need more than 80 countries, want Microsoft Copilot as an engine, or track AI shopping. Choose Firemark if you want to run AI visibility from Claude or ChatGPT, with an API on every paid plan and flat plans from $29 a month.Read the Peec AI comparison Comparison 02Profound vs Firemark
Choose Profound if you want an enterprise contract with up to nine engines and custom regions. Choose Firemark if you want to start today on a published price, set up in one conversation with your assistant and skip the sales call.Read the Profound comparison Comparison 03Otterly.AI vs Firemark
Choose Otterly.AI if you want a free trial without a card or 50+ countries. Choose Firemark if you want more prompts per dollar, Google AI Mode and Gemini in the plan price, and setup and changes from your assistant.Read the Otterly.AI comparisonBest AI visibility tools: how to choose
The best AI visibility tool covers the engines and markets your buyers use, prices by something you can predict, states how it scores answers, and fits the way your team works. Pick on the constraint that decides it for you.
You want to work from Claude or ChatGPT.
Firemark is MCP-native. Any member can set up a brand through a guided interview, read every result and change prompts, competitors and groups in the chat, with every change waiting for approval. See how MCP works.
You sell outside the United States.
Firemark tracks US English, plus French- and Spanish-speaking countries on request. Peec AI and Otterly.AI list more countries. See the Peec AI and Otterly.AI comparisons.
You want a published price and no sales call.
Firemark lists four monthly plans from $29 to $499. Profound lists a free Trial and a custom Enterprise plan for brands. See the Profound comparison.
You need the longest engine list.
Profound's Enterprise plan covers the longest engine list in the table above. Firemark tracks five: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, AI Overviews and AI Mode.
You want an API without an enterprise contract.
Firemark's read-only REST API is on every paid plan, from $29 a month. Peec AI and Profound list their APIs on Enterprise plans, and Otterly.AI from Standard.
You have to defend the numbers to a VP.
Ask every vendor for its minimum sample rules and what counts as a mention. Ours are on the method page.
Semrush and Ahrefs: AI visibility inside an SEO suite
Both sell AI visibility tracking alongside their SEO tools, which suits a team that already pays for one of them. We have not compared them point by point. The details below come from each vendor's own page, read on October 15, 2026.
Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit
Tracks mentions from ChatGPT, Google AI, Gemini and Perplexity, and includes 25 custom prompts. It is priced per domain, shown at €94.94 a month on annual billing on its EU pricing page.
Source: Semrush AI pricing page, checked 2026-10-15. Check Semrush for your currency and trial terms.
Ahrefs Brand Radar
Monitors AI Overviews, Gemini, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Copilot and AI Mode, and lists Claude as available. Its Custom Prompts option is listed from €47 a month.
Source: Ahrefs Brand Radar page, checked 2026-10-15. Check Ahrefs for your currency, plan limits and trial terms.
How we compared these tools
We read each vendor's own pricing page, docs and help pages on 2026-10-15. We state a competitor detail only when its own pages state it. When a vendor's pages disagree or leave a detail out, the page says to check the vendor instead of guessing.
Our own details come from our plans, our method and our MCP page. Firemark tracks five engines in US English, plus French- and Spanish-speaking countries on request, and gives a new account one free run. We name vendor pages as sources and do not link to them.
Peec AI sources
- Peec AI pricing pageChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: entry price and pricing unit; engine coverage; free trial; geography and language.
- Peec AI instructions pageChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: engine coverage; geography and language; answer-level data and export; methodology transparency.
- Peec AI MCP docs: toolsChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: MCP; answer-level data and export.
- Peec AI MCP docs: introductionChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: MCP.
- Peec AI API docs: introductionChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: API access.
Profound sources
- Profound pricing pageChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: entry price and pricing unit; engine coverage; free trial; geography and language; API access; answer-level data and export.
- Profound MCP docs: overviewChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: MCP.
- Profound REST API docs: introductionChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: API access; answer-level data and export.
- Profound help article: Answer Engine Insights overviewChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: methodology transparency.
Otterly.AI sources
- Otterly.AI pricing pageChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: entry price and pricing unit; engine coverage; geography and language; MCP; API access; answer-level data and export.
- Otterly.AI home pageChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: free trial.
- Otterly.AI MCP server docsChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: MCP; answer-level data and export.
- Otterly.AI alternatives pageChecked 2026-10-15. Used for: methodology transparency.
Peec AI, Profound, Otterly.AI and other vendor names on these pages are trademarks of their owners. We are not affiliated with them, and they have not reviewed these pages. Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we will check it.
Questions about comparing AI visibility tools
How is AI visibility different from SEO rank tracking?
Rank trackers report a position for a keyword on a results page. AI answers have no fixed positions. Firemark records whether your brand is named, whether the answer links to you and how competitors fare across many prompts and engines. It repeats this on a schedule.
How do I compare AI visibility tools?
Compare them on eight things: entry price and what the price scales with, engine coverage, free trial, geography and language, MCP, API access, answer-level data and export, and how openly the method is documented. Check each against the vendor's own pages, because plans and prices change often.
Will two AI visibility tools give me the same numbers?
No. Tools differ in the engines they track, how they collect answers, which country and language they ask from, how often they run and how many answers sit behind each figure. Compare a tool with itself over time, and compare tools on method rather than on one headline number.
How current is this comparison?
Competitor details come from each vendor's public pages and docs, checked on 2026-10-15, and each page lists its sources and dates. Vendors change prices and plans often, so confirm anything that decides your purchase on the vendor's own site.
Find out if AI recommends you
Start tracking your brand. New accounts get one free run.